Deutsche Gesellschaft
für phänomenologische Forschung

Series | Buch | Kapitel

194239

Otherness of self

Wolff-Michael Roth

pp. 141-158

Abstrakt

In an essay entitled "Facts and the Self from a Constructivist Point of View," Ernst von Glasersfeld takes a Kantian position and shows "how the cognizing subject builds up the idea of fellow experiencers who help to supply stability and a sense of objectivity to the experiential world." The author comes to accept a Cartesian ego as the basis of the human faith in the self as an active agent. The problem in this position is – shown in the ultimately futile effort of Edmund Husserl to establish an absolute science of the "I" – that we could never build up an understanding of others from the inside out, so to speak. In this chapter, I use interview excerpts in which a science teacher talk about herself and her teaching. I show how it is precisely because people talk about themselves that these Selves are generalized and inherently other. Speakers use genres for telling their auto/biographies, which are populated with characters and plots, so that who they are and can be always already is framed in terms of the other and the general. As a result, the Self is not built up from inside out, nor is it built from outside in.

Publication details

Published in:

Roth Wolff-Michael (2011) Passibility: at the limits of the constructivist metaphor. Dordrecht, Springer.

Seiten: 141-158

DOI: 10.1007/978-94-007-1908-8_8

Referenz:

Roth Wolff-Michael (2011) Otherness of self, In: Passibility, Dordrecht, Springer, 141–158.